Education for Complete Living (1938)

Australia, 1930-1960

Edited by Kenneth Cunningham, the first director of the Australian Council for Educational Research (ACER), this volume collected the papers given during the travelling conference of the New Education Fellowship through 1937.

Education for Complete Living was likely the most influential of any nongovernment publication about education and schooling in Australia in the first half of the twentieth century. The conference and publication occurred but a year or two before the beginning of the second world war. The conference was well aware of the coming conflagration. Laurin Zilliacus, the writer of the first chapter in Education for Complete Living titled it “The race between education and catastrophe”. He argued that the practical training of children and youth in democratic citizenship was a necessary part of the resistance to fascism and Nazism.

Cunningham 1

The title page

Despite the threat to world peace, the conference represented a further push for the progressive educational ideas that had become influential in Australia from the 1890s. It made sense that one of their main Australian proponents in the 1900-1920 period, Frank Tate, former Director of Education in Victoria, should introduce the volume of papers arising from the conference. However he took a defensive tone. Too many of the visiting speakers, educational experts, had been shocked by the centralisation and bureaucratic control over public education that occurred in the Australian states. Many were dismayed by the dominance of public examinations and the control by universities over school syllabuses, the weak links of schools to their parental communities, and the general  lack of freedom of teachers and schools to develop and experiment with curricula.

The New Education Fellowship (NEF) had been founded after the Great War in England, but soon developed local sections in many countries, including Australia and New Zealand. Beatrice Ensor, who came with the conference to Australia, was the NEF founder. Her and the NEF’s theosophical roots lent an idealist cast to NEF, but its education reform politics and activities developed well beyond these. By the 1930s it was the major international organisation that promoted the New Education. There were different approaches to educational reform contained within the publications and meetings of the NEF, and these may be also be seen in Education for Complete Living. Isaac Kandel for example, Professor of Education (Teachers College, Columbia University) was wary of the more radical speakers. Nevertheless, NEF members were usually agreed that progressive education could play a crucial role in the making of a better society.

Education for Complete Living, published the year after the travelling conference, was restricted in its immediate effects as war did indeed occur in 1939. Nevertheless it became a significant document for post-war educational reconstruction. Men involved in its genesis, including Cunningham, William Radford and Harold Wyndham, became key players in post-war educational reconstruction.

The travelling conference

The program was ambitious, beginning in Brisbane in early August, and concluding in Perth in mid September.

  • Brisbane, 4-6 August, 1937
    Cunningham 2

    Overarching statement on the purpose of education in modern times (p. v)

    Sydney, 9-16 August, 1937

  • Canberra, 18-20 August, 1937
  • Melbourne, 24-31 August, 1937
  • Hobart, 30 August-1 September, 1937
  • Adelaide, 3-9 September, 1937
  • Perth, 14-18 September 1937

Federal and state governments assisted with funding the project, with additional assistance from the Carnegie Corporation of New York (the original sponsor of the ACER), The Headmasters’ Conference of Australia (nongovernment schools) and a New Zealand conference committee. Many of the speakers had contributed to the NEF conference in New Zealand before they arrived in Australia.

The conference was a major event in each of the cities that it visited. Daily newspapers reported the proceedings. In some cities schools were closed allowing teachers to attend sessions. Teacher unions took notice, as did school and school system leaders. Those who attended sessions numbered in the thousands by the close of the conference in Perth. The editor of Education for Complete Living estimated that over the two months of conference, 21 speakers between them delivered over three hundred addresses, often in overcrowded lecture theatres and halls. The conference was big news in education, and the communities beyond.

Main speakers and contents of the publication

Cunningham 3

Beatrice Ensor, President of the NEF and conference speaker

Education for Complete Living is divided into 12 sections:

  1. Education and World Affairs
  2. The New Outlook in Education
  3. Education and Social Problems
  4. Education and Rural Life
  5. Educational Administration, Research, and Teacher Training
  6. Examinations
  7. The School Curriculum
  8. Special Aspects of Education
  9. Adolescent and Adult Education
  10. The University
  11. The Psychological and Mental Life of the School Child
  12. Summing Up

Other than the first section, that with the most papers (8) was no. 11. This included papers by some of the ‘stars’ of the conference, three by Susan Isaacs (London), two by Edward Malherbe (Pretoria), and one each by Harold Rugg (New York) and Beatrice Ensor (London).

Countries represented among the contributors included 10 from the United Kingdom (William Boyd, E. Salter Davies, Frank Debenham, Beatrice Ensor, H. R. Hamley, G. T. Hankin, F. C. Happold, Susan Isaacs, Percy Meadon and Cyril Norwood, 4 from the United States of America (Edmund de S. Brunner, F. W. Hart, Isaac Kandel and Harold Rugg), and 1 each from Switzerland (Piere Bovet), Austria (Paul L. Dengler), Canada (A. Lismer), South Africa (E. G. Malherbe), Denmark (Anders Vedel) and Finland (Laurin Zilliacus). The speaker from Japan (Yusuke Tsurumi) did not submit a paper for the publication.

Many of the speakers were internationally known, and some, such as Susan Isaacs and Cyril Norwood only became more significant over time, the first for her contribution to the child development field, and the second for an influential report leading to a reorganisation of post-war English schools.

The contribution to educational reform

The topics covered in Education for Complete Living are too many to list here.Nevertheless examples of the ways that its essays contributed to reforming primary and secondary education follow. The list is adapted from Campbell & Sherington (2006/2013, pp. 34-35). Not all of the conference speakers would have subscribed to the full list, but as a set of future ideals and aims, they had their effect on Australian school reform especially from the 1940s to the 1970s.

Cunningham 5

Prof. Isaac Kandel, Teachers’ College Columbia, conference speaker

  • Given the coming war, schools needed to be more committed to democracy, and capable of producing practical training in good citizenship
  • The school needed to do more than transmit existing knowledge and culture, schooling for a better, reconstructed social order was needed
  • Human wastage could no longer be tolerated, schools needed to develop all, not just the few
  • Schools needed to belong to their communities
  • Education had to be freed from the restrictions of central syllabuses and examination systems
  • Schools needed to be freed from the demands of universities which only took a tiny minority of the schooled
  • The arts, the cultivation of senses and emotions needed to enter the reformed curricula. The whole child or adolescent required attention
  • Education for leisure as well as work was required
  • Attention had to be given the ‘normal child’, not just the exceptional child: including health, the arts, literacy, vernacular language, numeracy and science, with a focus as well on religious, spiritual, moral and citizenship education
  • Social studies, the study of society needed to be part of the curriculum
  • Education needed to be anti-competitive, children should not fail.
  • Schools needed to be cognisant of the child’s emotional development. There was an important role for the child psychologist in schools. New knowledge about human development and child psychology needed to be applied to the educational and other needs of the young

There were some problems embedded within the progressive program outlined by Education for Complete Living. Teachers and educators were imagined almost solely as disinterested professionals, thereby underestimating many of the social, cultural and personal factors that led teachers to work as they did. Social class, gender and race were barely visible as issues that might profoundly affect educational practice and reform. There was little discussion of the capacity of school sector structure and hierarchies to affect reform. The differences between public, corporate and private schools barely entered the discussion. The papers, for all their democratic and community-building orientations, remained very much about educational experts prescribing reforms without much sensitivity to the problems that may arise from such a process.

Long term significance

Cunningham 4

Susan Isaacs, Institute of Education (London University, conference speaker

This book was not the only influence on educational reform in the 1920s to 1960s period. Criticisms of centralisation, the inflexible administration of public education, public examinations and narrow approaches to curricula and pedagogy existed elsewhere. Nevertheless the book was a major contribution to reform. The endorsement of the exercise by state education departments as well as reformers of various enthusiasms added to its legitimacy and influence. Isaac Kandel remained in Australia for a period after the conference, producing a further assessment of problems in Australian and New Zealand education. These were publications in 1938 (see Bibliography).

The influence of the conference and publication on the Minister of Education, David Drummond, in New South Wales is documented by Godfrey (2004). Harold Wyndham, the Director-General of Education who led substantial reform of public education, also in New South Wales in the 1950s and 1960s was a significant organiser of the conference in Sydney. The editor of Education for Complete Living, and his assistant, Kenneth Cunningham and William Radford respectively, remained influential figures through the ACER in educational administration and reform for many years. It was Radford’s report to the Queensland government in 1970 that led to the end of public examinations in that state. (They survived in all others.) The NEF itself, its branches and ad hoc committees established after the conference continued to press for reform into and after the 1940s. A major aim of the conference and publication was to interest, involve and mobilise the Australian public in matters of educational reform. There is evidence of fair success in this aim.

Note:

The author thanks Dr John Hughes for his assistance in the preparation of this entry.

 

 

 

 

Bibliography and References

Cunningham, K. S. (ed.) 1938. Education for complete living: The challenge of to-day, Melbourne: Melbourne University Press.

***

Campbell, C. & Sherington, G. 2006/2013. The comprehensive public high school: Historical perspectives, New York, Palgrave Macmillan.

Connell, W. F. 1980. The Australian Council for Educational Research, 1930-80, Melbourne, Australian Council for Educational Research.

Godfrey, J. 2004. ‘Perhaps the most important, and certainly the most exciting event in the whole history of education in Australia’: The 1937 New Education Fellowship Conference and New South Wales examination reform. History of Education Review, 33, 45-58.

Hughes, J. 2002. Harold Wyndham and educational reform in Australia 1925-1968. Education Research and Perspectives, 29, 1-268.

Hyams, B. K. & Bessant, B. 1972. Schools for the people? An introduction to the history of state education in Australia, Melbourne, Longman.

Kandel, I. 1938. Impressions of Australian education, Melbourne, ACER.

Kandel, I. L. 1938. Types of administration, Melbourne, ACER.

Larsson, Y. 1987. Pioneering progressive education: The World Education Fellowship in Australia and the world 1915-1987. New Era, 68, 53-64.

McCallum, D. 1990. The social production of merit: Education, psychology and politics in Australia 1900-1950, London, Falmer Press.

Selleck, R. J. W. 1968. The New Education, London, Pitman.

Spaull, A. D. 1982. Australian education in the Second World War, Brisbane, University of Queensland Press.

Turney, C. (ed.) 1983. Pioneers of Australian education, vol. 3, Sydney: Sydney University Press.

White, M. 1997. Carnegie philanthropy in Australia in the nineteen thirties – a reassessment. History of Education Review, 26, 1-24.

Williams, B. 1994. Education with its eyes open: A biography of K. S. Cunningham, Melbourne, ACER.

Citation of this entry

Campbell, C. 2014. Education for Complete Living (1938). Dictionary of Educational History in Australia and New Zealand (DEHANZ), 18 March. Available: http://dehanz.net.au

Keywords: , , , , , ,